Haunted things to do in New York City
Looking for haunted things to do in New York City? These 6 are the real ones — Green-Wood Cemetery Catacombs (After Hours Tour), Morris-Jumel Mansion and Conference House (Billopp Manor) among them — actual dark-history sites and genuinely unsettling places, not a seasonal haunted house with a fog machine. They spread across Greenwood Heights, Brooklyn, Washington Heights, Manhattan, Tottenville, Staten Island, Sleepy Hollow, NY (Westchester County) and 2 more areas, so two or three can make a whole afternoon. 2 of them cost nothing. Every entry is hand-vetted against real sources — not scraped off a top-ten list or averaged out of crowd ratings.
-
Green-Wood Cemetery Catacombs (After Hours Tour)
A 478-acre Victorian garden cemetery and National Historic Landmark where roughly 600,000 people are buried beneath rolling hills and Gothic gates. Hidden beneath one hillside are the Catacombs: 30 family vaults behind locked iron gates, an area closed to the public most of the year. After-hours evening tours wind through the grounds at dusk and into the normally-sealed catacomb tunnel.
-
Morris-Jumel Mansion
Built in 1765, this is the oldest surviving house in Manhattan, used by George Washington as a Revolutionary War headquarters. Socialite Eliza Jumel, who later married former vice president Aaron Burr, reportedly negotiated $2,000 off the asking price in 1810 by citing rumors it was haunted. Visitors describe a chatty apparition in 18th-century period dress, phantom footsteps, and objects moving on their own; the museum runs regular public paranormal investigations led by a resident ghost hunter.
-
Conference House (Billopp Manor)
A stone manor built around 1680 by Captain Christopher Billopp at the southern tip of Staten Island, overlooking the Arthur Kill. It hosted the failed 1776 Staten Island Peace Conference where Lord Howe met Benjamin Franklin and John Adams to try to end the Revolution. Long-told legends claim Billopp threw a servant girl down the stairs, and visitors and neighbors report apparitions, a singing or shouting man, and a woman's scream.
-
Sleepy Hollow Cemetery & Old Dutch Church
The 90-acre cemetery and the adjacent circa-1685 Old Dutch Church burying ground are the real-world settings of Washington Irving's 'The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,' and Irving himself is buried here under a modest headstone. The old churchyard is the storied haunt of the Headless Horseman. Two-hour evening tours guide visitors through the grounds by kerosene lantern light, past industrialists like Andrew Carnegie and William Rockefeller.
-
Civic Virtue ('Fat Boy')
This 17-foot MacMonnies marble group shows a heroic nude man, sword over his shoulder, standing atop two writhing female 'sirens' of Vice and Corruption. It was so reviled as sexist that Mayor La Guardia called it 'Fat Boy' and it was eventually exiled from a Queens Boulevard intersection. In 2012 it was hauled to Green-Wood Cemetery, where it now sits in genteel disgrace among the Victorian monuments.
-
Staten Island Boat Graveyard (Witte Marine Scrapyard)
In the Arthur Kill waterway sits a marine scrapyard where the rusting hulks of tugboats, ferries, and cargo ships slowly rot in the tidal mud. Founded in the 1930s by John J. Witte and still family-run, it once held some 400 vessels; today only a fraction remain, tilting at odd angles. It's a genuinely strange, post-industrial graveyard best appreciated from the shoreline at low tide or from a kayak (the yard itself is private and posted no-trespassing).
Haunted things to do in New York City — FAQ
Which haunted places & dark-history spots in New York City are the strangest?
Ranked by how strange they actually are: Morris-Jumel Mansion, Sleepy Hollow Cemetery & Old Dutch Church and Conference House (Billopp Manor). Morris-Jumel Mansion — Built in 1765, this is the oldest surviving house in Manhattan, used by George Washington as a Revolutionary War headquarters.
Where in New York City are they?
Across Greenwood Heights, Brooklyn, Washington Heights, Manhattan, Tottenville, Staten Island, Sleepy Hollow, NY (Westchester County) and Green-Wood Cemetery, Brooklyn and 1 more. Each listing gives the neighborhood and address so you can cluster a couple into one outing.
Are any of the haunted places & dark-history spots in New York City free?
Yes — 2 are free to visit, including Civic Virtue ('Fat Boy') and Staten Island Boat Graveyard (Witte Marine Scrapyard). The rest are mostly low-cost.
Is this a good weird date in New York City?
That's what the list is built for. Every entry has a specific move rather than a vague recommendation — at Morris-Jumel Mansion, for instance: Join a two-hour evening paranormal investigation and try to coax Eliza out of the period bedrooms with the resident ghost hunter.
How were these haunted places & dark-history spots chosen?
An agentic research system digs for the genuinely obscure — the spots even locals miss — and every one is verified against real sources before it makes the list. We deliberately skip the landmarks already on every New York City guide.