Entry No. 87 — the Denver file — filed under: records
Sold Out Vinyl Records
Westword crowned this Best Suburban Record Store in 2025 and called it 'easy to miss but well worth discovering' - which is exactly right, because it's set back from Broadway in an utterly unmarked Englewood strip mall. Owner Joe Magoonaugh, a Chicago transplant, grew the whole thing out of an online concert-poster hustle, and the shop now holds 100,000-plus records with only pristine copies put out on the floor. The layout is small but doesn't feel it, the prices are fair, and the service is genuinely doting. You'd drive past it a hundred times and never know.
The story
Most record heads driving down South Broadway stop around Antique Row and turn back, completely oblivious to the unmarked mini strip mall at 3751 S Broadway. Sunk back from the street with no sign pointing to it from Broadway, Sold Out Vinyl Records sits hidden away in Englewood’s south end. You could drive past the parking lot a hundred times and never guess that over 100,000 records, cassette tapes, CDs, and rare concert prints are packed behind those plain glass storefronts.
Owner Joe Magoonaugh didn't set out as a record store mogul. A Chicago transplant with fifteen years in the restaurant industry, he moved to Colorado in 2020 and turned a personal poster hustle—hatched after missing out on a gig print at a 2007 Eric Clapton festival—into an online shop called Sold Out Posters. That operation slowly expanded into physical media, taking root in this Englewood strip mall before doubling its floor space in early 2025.
What separates this shop from typical suburban record dumps is the strict filtering: only pristine, clean copies actually make it onto the floor racks. Staff will literally walk out to your car to help carry heavy record crates inside if you're bringing a collection to sell, while inside you flip through spotless pressings beneath authentic, first-edition concert posters lining the walls.
What it's like
Pull into the strip mall lot, park for free, and look for the storefront set back from the main road. Inside, rows of crates and poster racks fill the room without feeling crammed or chaotic. Show up on a weekend morning if you want first crack at the newly graded stock, or slide in during Sunday's quieter hours to dig in peace. If you're hauling in boxes to sell, leave them in the trunk for a minute—the staff will walk outside and do the heavy lifting for you.
The move: Go on a weekend, hunt for a record that means something to one of you, and grab a limited concert poster on the way out to hang somewhere you'll both see it.
📍 Before you go It's at the south end of Broadway in Englewood, not the famous Antique Row blocks farther north - and it's genuinely easy to blow past, since it sits set back inside an unmarked mini strip mall with no Broadway-facing sign. Trust your GPS, pull into the shopping-center lot (there's free off-street parking), and look for it tucked among the storefronts. Weekend mornings get you first pick of freshly graded stock; Sunday hours are the soft spot, so check ahead. Selling records too? Staff will help haul crates in from your car. Afterward, make a day of it and browse north up Broadway's long vintage-and-thrift corridor.
- 📍 Englewood / South Broadway
- 💸 $
- ⚡ Low-key
- 🌗 Indoors
Where: 3751 S Broadway, Englewood, CO 80113 (set back inside an unmarked mini strip mall off Broadway)
Hours: Mon-Sat 10am-7pm (Sun hours vary; some listings show Sun 10am-5pm). Confirm before going.
Pair it with
- Garibaldi Mexican Bistro — Fuel up on Mexico City street food inside a Conoco gas station just half a mile down South Broadway after digging through record bins.
- HORRID — Pair your vinyl run with a quick stop for horror oddities and macabre collectibles tucked just off Broadway behind the Brutal Poodle.
- Fifty-Two 80s: A Totally Awesome Shop — Continue your physical media crawl up South Broadway to flip through thousands of 1980s pop-culture relics, toys, and nostalgia pieces.
- Ante Up — Head two miles north to pair your record digging with a visit to an all-ages, substance-free DIY punk and emo space.
Good to know
How do I find Sold Out Vinyl Records from Broadway?
Look for 3751 S Broadway in Englewood; the shop sits set back inside an unmarked mini strip mall with no Broadway-facing sign, but there is a free parking lot directly out front.
What media and inventory do they carry?
They stock over 100,000 pristine vinyl records, cassette tapes, CDs, and original first-edition screen-printed concert posters across all genres.
Does the shop buy record collections or concert posters?
Yes, they buy used vinyl, CDs, cassette tapes, and limited-edition concert prints, and staff will help haul heavy crates into the store from your car.
What are the store's hours?
They are open Monday through Saturday from 10am to 7pm. Sunday hours vary (often 10am to 5pm), so it is smart to check ahead before heading over.
Plan a visit & invite your people →
Further reading: Official site · Westword · coloradocommunitymedia.com
last checked: 2026-06-07